Skip to content
Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookies

Peanut Butter and Jelly Cookies

  • Makes: about 40 cookies  
  • Preparation Time: 10 minutes plus baking time 

Ingredients

1 can300 ml Regular or Low Fat Eagle Brand® sweetened condensed milk

1 cup250 ml smooth peanut butter

1 egg

2 tsp10 ml vanilla extract

2 cups500 ml all-purpose flour

1 tsp5 ml baking soda

1/4 tsp1 ml salt

Favourite variety of jelly or jam

Directions

  1 :  Beat Eagle Brand with peanut butter, egg and vanilla until smooth. Mix in flour, baking soda and salt until well blended.

  2 :  Shape into 1" (2.5 cm) balls. Place 2" (5 cm) apart on parchment paper-lined baking sheets. Press thumb in centre of each ball; fill with jelly or jam.

  3 :  Bake in preheated 375ºF (190ºC) oven for 12 minutes or until lightly browned; transfer to rack to cool.

More recipes you’ll love

  • Peanut Butter and Jam Bars
    Peanut Butter and Jam Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes
    View recipe
  • Dark Chocolate Granola Bars
    Dark Chocolate Granola Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Oat Bars
    Chocolate Peanut Butter Oat Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes
    View recipe
  • Pumpkin Crumble Cheesecake Bars
    Pumpkin Crumble Cheesecake Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Easy Pumpkin Ice Cream Bars
    Easy Pumpkin Ice Cream Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes
    View recipe
  • Coconut Macaroon Nests
    Coconut Macaroon Nests

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Sweet & Salty Chip Bars
    Sweet & Salty Chip Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes, plus chilling
    View recipe
  • Pumpkin Praline Squares
    Pumpkin Praline Squares

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Lemon Cranberry Macaroons
    Lemon Cranberry Macaroons

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes
    View recipe
  • Carrot and Apple Morning Glory Drops
    Carrot and Apple Morning Glory Drops

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Easter Blossoms
    Easter Blossoms

    Prep Time:
    45 minutes
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Marshmallow Magic Bars
    Chocolate Marshmallow Magic Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes, plus chilling time
    View recipe
  • Nutty Dulce de Leche Shortbread Bars
    Nutty Dulce de Leche Shortbread Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Dulce de Leche Shortbread Bars
    Dulce de Leche Shortbread Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Dulce de Leche Macadamia Nut Cookies
    Dulce de Leche Macadamia Nut Cookies

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes
    View recipe
  • Apple Dulce de Leche Oat Bars
    Apple Dulce de Leche Oat Bars

    Prep Time:
    25 minutes

    View recipe
  • Muesli Bars
    Muesli Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes
    View recipe
  • Sweet and Salty Chocolate Caramel Bars
    Sweet and Salty Chocolate Caramel Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes
    View recipe
  • Vanilla Bliss Bars
    Vanilla Bliss Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes
    View recipe
  • Little Monsters
    Little Monsters

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes, plus chilling time
    View recipe
  • Peanut Butter, Chocolate and Walnut Magic Bars
    Peanut Butter, Chocolate and Walnut Magic Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Cookies
    Peanut Butter and Chocolate Chip Cookies

    Prep Time:
    30 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • No Bake Chocolate Pecan Brownie
    No Bake Chocolate Pecan Brownie

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Divine Dark Chocolate Squares
    Divine Dark Chocolate Squares

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • A Slice of Nuts
    A Slice of Nuts

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes
    View recipe
  • Peanut Butter Fudge Bars
    Peanut Butter Fudge Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

    Cook Time:
    28 minutes
    View recipe
  • Chewy Gooey Granola Bites
    Chewy Gooey Granola Bites

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes, plus cooling

    Cook Time:
    17 minutes
    View recipe
  • Chewy Chocolate Nut Clusters
    Chewy Chocolate Nut Clusters

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes, plus chilling time
    View recipe
  • Chewy Fruit & Nut Bars
    Chewy Fruit & Nut Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes
    View recipe
  • Cranberry Apricot Almond Magic Shortbread Bars
    Cranberry Apricot Almond Magic Shortbread Bars

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes plus baking and time
    View recipe
  • Butterscotch Pecan Crunch Squares
    Butterscotch Pecan Crunch Squares

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • S’more Squares
    S’more Squares

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Gingerbread Cookies
    Gingerbread Cookies

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus chilling and baking time
    View recipe
  • Dreamy Orange Bars
    Dreamy Orange Bars

    Prep Time:
    30 minutes
    View recipe
  • S’mores on a Stick
    S’mores on a Stick

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes, plus 30 minutes cooling time

    Cook Time:
    3 minutes
    View recipe
  • Morning Glories
    Morning Glories

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

    Cook Time:
    45 minutes
    View recipe
  • Trailblazers Cookies
    Trailblazers Cookies

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Sweet and Salty Fudge Bars
    Sweet and Salty Fudge Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes

    Cook Time:
    1-2 hours
    View recipe
  • Zebra Bars
    Zebra Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Crisps
    Chocolate Crisps

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

    Cook Time:
    10 minutes
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Cookie Slice
    Chocolate Cookie Slice

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes
    View recipe
  • Triple Chocolate Chip Sandwich Cookies
    Triple Chocolate Chip Sandwich Cookies

    Prep Time:
    30 minutes

    Cook Time:
    12 minutes
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie Cheesecake Bites
    Chocolate Chip Cookie Cheesecake Bites

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Key Lime Coconut Squares
    Key Lime Coconut Squares

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • White Chocolate Cheesecake Squares with Dark Chocolate Glaze
    White Chocolate Cheesecake Squares with Dark Chocolate Glaze

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking and chilling time
    View recipe
  • White Chocolate and Almond Magic Bars
    White Chocolate and Almond Magic Bars

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes plus baking and time
    View recipe
  • Walnut Cappuccino Bars
    Walnut Cappuccino Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Tropical Magic Cookie Bars
    Tropical Magic Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Trail Mix Cookie Bars
    Trail Mix Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    8 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Top Hat Triple Layer Bars
    Top Hat Triple Layer Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Toffee-Topped Pecan Bars
    Toffee-Topped Pecan Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Toffee-Top Cheesecake Bars
    Toffee-Top Cheesecake Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Walnut Squares
    Chocolate Walnut Squares

    Prep Time:
    25 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Tartly Frosted Lemon Squares
    Tartly Frosted Lemon Squares

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Super Fudgey Chocolate Cookies
    Super Fudgey Chocolate Cookies

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus chilling and baking time
    View recipe
  • Sunny Citrus Bars
    Sunny Citrus Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Sugary Lemon Twists
    Sugary Lemon Twists

    Prep Time:
    60 minutes
    View recipe
  • Succulent Raspberry Chocolate Squares
    Succulent Raspberry Chocolate Squares

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Snowy Coconut Macaroons
    Snowy Coconut Macaroons

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • S’mores
    S’mores

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Rocky Road Squares
    Rocky Road Squares

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Quick Coconutty Bars
    Quick Coconutty Bars

    Prep Time:
    8 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Pistachio Magic Cookie Bar
    Pistachio Magic Cookie Bar

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Pecan Pie Bars
    Pecan Pie Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Peanut Magic Cookie Bars
    Peanut Magic Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Peanut Butter and Chocolate Shortbread Bars
    Peanut Butter and Chocolate Shortbread Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Cherry Chews
    Chocolate Cherry Chews

    Prep Time:
    5 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Oatmeal Fudge Bars
    Oatmeal Fudge Bars

    Prep Time:
    18 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • No-Bake Fudgey Brownies
    No-Bake Fudgey Brownies

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus chilling time
    View recipe
  • Nanaimo Bars
    Nanaimo Bars

    Prep Time:
    25 minutes plus chilling time
    View recipe
  • Multiple Choice Magic Cookie Bars
    Multiple Choice Magic Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Cranberry Cheesecake Bars
    Cranberry Cheesecake Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Maple Scented Banana Bread
    Maple Scented Banana Bread

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Magic Santa Cookie Bar
    Magic Santa Cookie Bar

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Magic Rainbow Cookie Bars
    Magic Rainbow Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Magic Marshmallow Bars
    Magic Marshmallow Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Magic Cookie Bars
    Magic Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    8 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Magic Chocolate Toffee Bar
    Magic Chocolate Toffee Bar

    Prep Time:
    8 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Macaroon Cookie Bars
    Macaroon Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Macaroon Kisses
    Macaroon Kisses

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Lemony Cheesecake Bars
    Lemony Cheesecake Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Lemon Sugar Cookies
    Lemon Sugar Cookies

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus chilling time
    View recipe
  • Lemon Shortbread Bars
    Lemon Shortbread Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Krispy Butterscotch Squares
    Krispy Butterscotch Squares

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Butterscotch Brownies
    Chocolate Butterscotch Brownies

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Heavenly White Chocolate Toffee Bars
    Heavenly White Chocolate Toffee Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes
    View recipe
  • Hazelnut Chocolate Truffles
    Hazelnut Chocolate Truffles

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus chilling time
    View recipe
  • White Chocolate Fruit Bars
    White Chocolate Fruit Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Gingered Lemon Cookies
    Gingered Lemon Cookies

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking and chilling time
    View recipe
  • Fudgey Brownie Bars
    Fudgey Brownie Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Fruity Lemon Crumb Bars
    Fruity Lemon Crumb Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Butterscotch Squares
    Butterscotch Squares

    Prep Time:
    4 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Double the Magic Cookie Bars
    Double the Magic Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    12 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Double Delicious Cookie Bars
    Double Delicious Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Double Chocolate Brownies
    Double Chocolate Brownies

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Toffee Crisp Squares
    Toffee Crisp Squares

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes
    View recipe
  • Decadent Double Chocolate Cookies
    Decadent Double Chocolate Cookies

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus chilling and baking time
    View recipe
  • Decadent Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie Bars
    Decadent Double Chocolate Brownie Cookie Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Dainty Caramel Triangles
    Dainty Caramel Triangles

    Prep Time:
    15 min. plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Crunchy Lemon Squares
    Crunchy Lemon Squares

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Coffee Almond Macaroons
    Coffee Almond Macaroons

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Spicy Chocolate Drops
    Spicy Chocolate Drops

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Streusel Cream Cheese Bar
    Chocolate Streusel Cream Cheese Bar

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Streusel Bars
    Chocolate Streusel Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Pecan Bars
    Chocolate Pecan Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Peanut Graham Squares
    Chocolate Peanut Graham Squares

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Peanut Bars
    Chocolate Peanut Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus chilling time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Oatmeal Mini Macaroons
    Chocolate Oatmeal Mini Macaroons

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Nut Bars
    Chocolate Nut Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Mint Cheesecake Bars
    Chocolate Mint Cheesecake Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Diamonds
    Chocolate Diamonds

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Crunch Bars
    Chocolate Crunch Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Chip Toffee Bars
    Chocolate Chip Toffee Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Chip Orange Brownies
    Chocolate Chip Orange Brownies

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Cookies
    Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Cookies

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chocolate Caramel Shortbread
    Chocolate Caramel Shortbread

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time (microwave method)
    View recipe
  • Chocolate ´n Oat Bars
    Chocolate ´n Oat Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Chewy Chocolate Toffee Squares
    Chewy Chocolate Toffee Squares

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes
    View recipe
  • Chewy Chocolate Cranberry Bars
    Chewy Chocolate Cranberry Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Candy Bar Bars
    Candy Bar Bars

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Butterscotch Chocolate Oatmeal Squares
    Butterscotch Chocolate Oatmeal Squares

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes

    Cook Time:
    25 minutes
    View recipe
  • Apple Butterscotch Cookies
    Apple Butterscotch Cookies

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Brownie Cheesecake Bars
    Brownie Cheesecake Bars

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Apricot Coconut Squares
    Apricot Coconut Squares

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Apple Crumble Cream Cheese Squares
    Apple Crumble Cream Cheese Squares

    Prep Time:
    25 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Apple Cinnamon Streusel Coffee Cake
    Apple Cinnamon Streusel Coffee Cake

    Prep Time:
    20 minutes plus baking time
    View recipe
  • Almond Fudge Topped Shortbread
    Almond Fudge Topped Shortbread

    Prep Time:
    15 minutes plus chilling time
    View recipe
  • Sweet & Salty Granola Bars
    Sweet & Salty Granola Bars

    Prep Time:
    10 minutes

    Cook Time:
    30 minutes
    View recipe